RESEARCH / COMPARISON

The simpler solution
belongs in the test.

Equal information for algorithm comparisons. Added hardware carries its mass, power, integration and lifecycle cost.

Proposed comparisons, not performance results
MethodWhat it contributesWhat must be established
B0 / Engineered recoveryInterlocks, retries, safe abort and documented recoveryA competent baseline with the same information
B1 / Operator assistanceTrained human recovery under stated communicationsRealistic delay, information and intervention burden
B2 / Simpler hardwareAn independent sensor or passive improvementIndependence, diagnostic coverage and full system cost
C / Candidate methodExplicit reasoning over possible physical statesUseful improvement that survives the simpler alternatives

Before a result can count

Define the task. Bind the physical states, guards, limits, faults and measurements to a real interface.

Freeze the comparison. Set endpoints, exclusions, held-out cases and stopping rules before evaluation.

Keep every outcome. Report unsafe events, safe aborts, interventions and completion separately. Eventual completion does not erase a violation.

CARTAN / CONCEPT FILM

The mission continues.

Concept imagery: orbital assembly, an exploded-module study and a service-bay exchange. These depict different proposed systems, not one verified machine or a validated sequence. Ending notice: “AI-generated design concepts. Not engineering validation.”

Read the film’s visual description

Orbital construction opens the ambition. A white-background exploded module follows. A gripped cartridge approaches a service bay, followed by an editorial close-up. Orbital assembly then continues. The final card shows the CARTAN logo, “Built to change,” and “AI-generated design concepts. Not engineering validation.” No footage validates a connection, retention or recovery; the systems are different concept illustrations.